Mafia IV - Lord of the Rings -

[Daekesh]

I am a Red.  Want to make a deal with the Dark Lord?  For each Blue that reveals themselves, I will, once per day, reveal a Red player.

[Palmar]

Wow.

Okay, so here's something to discuss, this is the order in which we will lynch people, from highest priority to lowest.

Scum -> Liars -> Stupid -> Default to lynching Nach.

[Eetion]

Interesting way to start of the game Matt, dare i say, "pulling an Archz?" ..

I must agree with Palmar, there have been alot of "lynching stupid/thought to be bad" people.. In most cases, it has pretty much only been because of the stupid and rather harmless behaviour (couldnt find a better term really), that have made them a lynch target, rather than actual threats. So there would be alot of sense in not lynching "archz like"/rookie players right off the bat just because they who they are..
The game is still young, but definetly a topic that is worth a real thought for everyone palmar.
Also, i would advertise the power of a townie to the new people that might have this role, even though it might seem meaningless to speak up some times, every word from a townie can help in a way to uncover scums. Speaking up is one of the strongest powers in this game, without it there wouldnt be much basis to go from, and hunt people down from. I'm bringing it up because there have been a lot of the new people in our other games who has been, i would say afraid, to speak up. Maybe because they were afraid to get lynched.. But the everything gives imformation, good or bad lynch, good or bad kill. Everything is important. Atleast this is what ive come down to after the couple of games i've been in. 

[Skymunken]

Why would Matt reveal that he is red with the power to reveal other reds for each blue that also reveals themselves? As a new player that seems rather counter-productive?

Or am I missing the point ?

[Surim]

With Matt admitting he is a Red comes with many questions. Is he actually going to reveal who is red, or will he give blue players names so that we lynch them instead of a red? There must be some power or alternative reason that he would admit that he is a red? Dont trust his word unless we have a bit of evidence that what he is saying is true?

[mayx]

So you're saying he is bluff/lying?

[Surim]

Not saying that he is bluffing. Don't think anybody would admit to being red for no reason, but what I am saying that if he is scum (which he claims to be) can we trust what he posts?

Edit: where are the other players?

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

As always post editing is not allowed!

[Surim]

Oh shit. Completely forgot about that. Thought it was pointless to write a new post just to ask where the other people are

[Palmar]

Ok here is a suggestion.

What we do is we use a RNG to select the day 1 lynch. Is everyone happy with the idea?

[Surim]

Sounds good. How we going to RNG it?

[Skymunken]

Theres over 24 hours till the day ends, by that point someone is probably gonna say something and we can start our witch-hunt.

Im not saying that this first day is gonna be major rng when it comes to lynching, but we shouldnt assume thats how we should do it without having just a little discussion as well.

If that makes sense

[Yoica]

Why would we agree to RNG when we still have 30+ hrs of possible posting? RNG statistically favors the reds and should, imo, only be used if we've had no mistakes by tomorrow 18ish.

[Palmar]

Prove that it statistically favours red yoica.

Until you can, I want to lynch you.

[Skymunken]

Well RNG could go both ways.

It puts the ball in the red hands though since they know whos red.