Mafia - The story of Edgeville - Town Square

[Kawe / Dave]

Interesting that you should say I voted for shankski before you, very interesting... I never once voted for Shanks, let alone before you. I also never said that I trusted Nach. Truth is I was pretty unsure between hug and nach for the crony role. However, stepping back, looking at the way Nach is going at you now and how Hug was going at Arches after also berating him for no tracker info,  and calling him into question over if he was actually hooked does make a very neat little picture of the game if hug was the hooker.

I'm also in the situation of not having a clue about what a Grishnag gambit is... part of your plan? Tnx god for no post editing rule.

[Tyler]

Sorry my bad, you voted for Grax not Shank.

[Tyler]

Ah the feigned ignorance approach. When all else fails pretend you are deaf...

You know the Grishnag gambit. The thing you did where the mob killed Grish so that Kawe could pretend to be a veteran. The mob _have_ to kill two people when they have more than two members left. The only explanation I ever got for Grish?s death was from Kawe. He said that Dell had asked ninjas to make themselves known to him on IRC in day 2.

Besides the fact that no ninja, despite how persuasive Dell can be, would ever have done this. Why would anyone target Grish. Even Dell would surely have picked a different target. Hug and/or Arches are gonna kick themselves about this tonight if they go ahead and lynch me. I mean it?s one thing not to guess, but to ignore it when it has been pointed out is gonna smart some.

[Tyler]

Turns out I've made another mistake. The mob dont have to use 2 kills. I guess they just all have to vote or get mod killed,

So maybe Grish was a mob Kill.

I'll see ya'll on the gallows

[Kawe / Dave]

Wow. Talk about clutching at straws... is it even possible for mafia to kill themselves? Though I suppose it's only as exepcted that you'd have thought of the most outlandish mafia plays, after having yourself framed while insisting Vorte investigate you twice in a row. Nice that you had a fancy name for your plan, too.

[Tyler]

So wait.

You think I?m the godfather? 

You also think I guessed Vorte would investigate me, the most vocal villager, twice in a row?

You finally think the mob decided to use Cwave?s frame to finger me. So that the second invsetigation I would prove myself to be innocent?

At least I?m not the only one with whacky ideas.

[Kawe / Dave]

You hardly had to guess that Vorte would investigate you when you had such great trust from him and I, and could simply suggest him to do so, act shocked and ask for it again to claim innocence. Claiming now to 'not be the one with whacky ideas', after coming out with a mob-on-mob kill plan with its own special title is pretty rich. Not to mention you glossed over nicely that the you self-framing idea is one I initially doubted when Grax presented it as an idea; I thought it unlikely for at the time.

However, now you're telling me that that a self-frame is not just unlikely but whacky,  while simultaneously saying a mob not only framing themselves but killing themselves, when their numbers are their basis for winning the game, is not. I don't know if you could manage to be more inconsistant in a single post. That said, I suppose it makes sense that you'd consider one seemingly crazy plan natural, while denying another less so as 'whacky' - since it's the one that's been spotted.

Vorte described the situation with Tyler as a mob boss as his "oh fuck" situation, and I have to agree with him on that much. Until Grax pointed out the self-frame possibility and then died a townie, and until you started making these slip ups now I would never have believed it. Or maybe I didn't want to believe I'd been fooled by you so badly. Either way, as I believe you put it to Shiftey while you lead us on to his lynching, "the jig is up".

[Tyler]

My idea that the mob passed up a kill one night so that you could claim veteran still holds. The Grish part is unexplained.

Your idea is complicated by the need for the mob to predict how Vorte, the ninja pretending to be a cop, would behave two nights in a row. If I was godfather I think I would have relied on my immunity.

[Kawe / Dave]

Maybe I'd believe that you'd have relied on your immunity if you weren't getting eyeballed by Grax, who it seems had your number a good bit earlier than the rest of us.

And saying you needed to predict vorte's behaviour is again ignoring not only that you had his trust to readily abuse, but also that even if he hadn't then agreed to check you a second time, it was simple enough for you to claim framing as you did so heavily. Even if people didn't believe you for sure at that point, you'd have cast the doubt in their minds.

Once again you say 'my' idea is complicated, after presenting your own seemingly more bizarre one as though it was obvious - though to you it would be if you perpetrated it. A series of complicated plans, then declare them 'too complicated' ... except when you make a slip up and reveal one no one knew about till now.

[Tyler]

This is why posting is good. The door is now open for Arches and Hug to choose which argument they think is more likely.

Hopefully they won't repeat the mistakes I made when voting for Shiftey, Shanks, Grax. It will be a glorious feeling if they save the day by lynching Nach

[Hugman]

Arches you are so dumb.

[Tyler]

I made some big mistakes in this game, and a few smaller ones.

The first was to not understand how the cop and godfather roles work. Early game I thought the cop could discover roles, and that the godfather would show up as a villager.

The second was to think that the mob had to kill twice in a night when they could.

The third was more strat. Maybe I should have played my cards closer to my chest. It does look bad when you accuse someone who then turns out to be innocent. It might be good to let the mobsters incriminate themselves more before I accuse.

The mob have had an easy time of it. One slight of hand and they were able to sit back while we fought amongst ourselves. Even when we got another life, them killing the ninja, we are going to waste it...

The only real facts we villagers have are the voting records. Mine is better than both Nach and Kawe, even with the fuck ups. The next closest thing are the claims that people make. We have one confimed and one claimed veteran. The simple act of passing up on one mob kill is going to win them the game. Kawe has made this out to be a complex ruse, but really its not.

I am still hopeful Arches will change his mind and come to the rescue. Here's to hope.

[Palmar]

Night Descends!


Tyler loaded up his guns, he had accepted what his fate would be. Outside the sounds of the angry mob that wanted his blood grew ever louder. Tyler had lead the town to three unwarranted executions.

"I'm not going down without a fight" - Tyler said to the Executioner. Goza pulled off his hood and nodded. He'd never said much.

"This is it, no one can blame me for not trying to save this town"

Tyler ripped open the door to his home and rushed out guns blazing with Goza running right after him.






As soon as the door opened they were hammered with bullets. There was never much chance they'd get far, before reaching the street they were lying on the ground, bleeding the same innocent blood as so many had before them.

Several members of the maddened crowd fell in the gunfight, most notably Arches took a bullet to the head, and then another punctured his heart. He'd never used his head much, but no one can live without their heart.



Tyler the Villager has died a bloody death
Goza the Executioner has died a bloody death
Arches the Tracker has been shot



The sound of the gunfight was muffled, but Kawe leaned back and allowed himself a smile for the first time in days. He knew exactly what this meant. The town was finally his. Edgeville would forever exist in his shadow.

The Godfather didn't smile often.

Even after knowing him such long time Nachmanun still felt uneasy whenever the Kawe showed any sign of emotion. You could never tell if it was good or bad.

But the Godfather simply gave Nachmanun a nod and handed him the poison. This had been planned long ago.

Nachmanun had a date tonight, a date with Hugman...







Hugman the Miller has been poisoned and killed



The Mafia has taken over Edgeville!

Congratulations:
Kawe the Mafia Godfather
Nachmanun the Mafia Escort
Cwave the Mafia Framer
TTaM the Mafia Goon
Grishnag the Mafia Goon

[Nachmanun]

 

[shankski]

Well GZ mafia especially Kawe good job man.

Awesome game will there be another one soon?