Mafia V - World of Warcraft Legion -

[Hugman]

There are 10 town and 3 Mafia.

Surely as town it's better to lose a possible townie who's is going to be mod liked anyway, rather than losing up to two townies in one night, one to mod kill, one to lynch?

Sure we lose the slim chance of getting a Mafia kill day one, but that's low anyway.

[Cwave]

I see that Arch also switched. So if hug switches to Shimmar as well it means he'll get 4 votes which only further increases the mafia's influence!

Remember townies get NO usefull info on the ppl who voted for Shimmar, because voting for someone you know if going to die is useless.

Yoica, do not edit your posts!

[Yoica]

There are 10 town and 3 Mafia.

Surely as town it's better to lose a possible townie who's is going to be mod liked anyway, rather than losing up to two townies in one night, one to mod kill, one to lynch?

Sure we lose the slim chance of getting a Mafia kill day one, but that's low anyway.

Yes, but if 4 townie vote for a player getting killed that means there are 6 townie vs 3 mafia for a lynch. This is only  advantageous for the maffia.

Currently my suspicio-meter is saying

1. Inexcutis - statistically narrators are mafia more often not mafia. Have to make 1st night choice based on something right?
1. Phoenix - tied 1st, as mouse mentioned the aggressive stance, but not actually voting while pushing to vote. This actually makes me doubt my vote
2. Hugman - As grill mentioned the pattern in posts between Hug and Phoenix.
3. completely open for me still.

Sorry Cwave, wouldn't do it again!

[Hugman]

Right now I am doubting what to do.

My main hesitation, aside from ,Yoica points, is that Arches changed his vote to Shimmar BEFORE the time i said I was going to switch, which kinda makes me feel I am being played.

This is all Shimmars fault, FUCK YOU Shimmar! You fucking baddie!

[Archz]

Gotta agree with Hugman here. I might be a noob, I haven't played all that much, but I don't see how we get so much more information from just lynching someone at random. Sure voting pattern is important, and if all 12 vote for Shimmar then we got nothing from voting, but how would that be any different say if you all lynched me?

Don't we also rely heavily the other townies with special roles that can investigate players etc?

[Hugman]

Right back to plan A, sticking with Vorte. We will sort it out I the morning.

Fuck you Shimmar, may your mod kill be exceptionally dishonourable.

[Cwave]

As the day came to an end, the angry mob of Iron Edge Raiders reached a verdict. Two raiders tied into a final vote where one would get lynched. Normal rules would dictate that the first one getting the most votes would be the one to hang, but something didn't feel right about that this time.

They called upon the old gods to make a final verdict between these two. Gods don't like afk-ers so the grim final vote fell onto Shimmar. Due to the nature of his crime, the possible murder of Cwave AND being afk in trying to find the suspects, the old gods ported him out into the pit of C'thun to be ravaged by tentacles for a 1000 years.

Shimmar the Vanilla Townie has been raped by C'thun

It's now Night 1. Actions have to be in before 23:00 GMT+1 tonight.

•   Welcome, Shimmar, you are one of the elite Iron Edge Raiders, a Vanilla Townie.

Abilities:
•   You have your voice and your vote. Be active and lynch the mafia!!!

Win condition:
•   You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated and there is at least one town player alive.

[Cwave]

From the rules:

As a general rule, modkills should be designed to be as disadvantageous to the player and their faction as possible. A modkill on Town will end the Day (thus preventing them from lynching), and a modkill on any kind of scum will keep the Day going (so that the Town can ideally lynch another scum).

[Grilldyret]

What a way to go.. In true Grishnag-fashion with a tentacle in every hole.

Important clarification, Cwave. I think we were all under the impression that there would be both a modkill and a lynch today. However, this rule kind of favors the mafia as they are less likely to get modkilled (Due to the nature of their role). On the first day it could have gone both ways though, so I'm not too bummed about it!

[Cwave]

What a way to go.. In true Grishnag-fashion with a tentacle in every hole.

Important clarification, Cwave. I think we were all under the impression that there would be both a modkill and a lynch today. However, this rule kind of favors the mafia as they are less likely to get modkilled (Due to the nature of their role). On the first day it could have gone both ways though, so I'm not too bummed about it!

Modkilling is shit yep . A modkill and a lynch is too much(more so in this 13 sized game), hence the rule that a modkill stops any lynches.

PS. Posting during the night is allowed this game, just to be clear.

[Tyler]

So Shimmar's mod-kill meant that there would have been no lynch, no matter what the vote count?

[Cwave]

So Shimmar's mod-kill meant that there would have been no lynch, no matter what the vote count?

Sadly, yes. It's why afk-ers suck balls!

[Tyler]

Indeed they do...

OK well at least we know we do not need to alter our votes to an AFKer then. Just go ahead and vote for the person we think is most likely to be scum.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

I don't think there is much more to discuss until the next corpse turns up.

[Grilldyret]

I don't think there is much more to discuss until the next corpse turns up.

Unless the doctor puts its LoH on Hugman /Phoenix and lucks out in a 50/50 draw!