Mafia V - World of Warcraft Legion -

[Mouseh]

Hugman being godfather would be freaking awesome!

[Fulskar]

Nice! Well played Hugman, I was worried how it might look if Rash turned out to be Townie or even Special Role townie, getting a Mafia this early is a success. But to think we could have done it with Shimmar and Grishnag intact.. Damn if you turn out to be the godfather though...

Archz is that a serious suggestion to lynch Hugman?

Yoica I can see why Hugman would be murdered he was very vocal and aggressive but why do you think you'd be next to go? I will read the post you link from the previous game, just posting quickly in bed ATM.

Can someone who has time do another vote analysis.

Phoenix is yet to convince me he is town, I'd like to see a convincing argument he's town as he's currently sat top of my suspects list. For the same reasons as yesterday.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

So why didn't Rash fight for his life? Why did nobody try to defend him?

Clever mafia would make sure both of the other mafia got on that kill rash bandwagon to get some credit.

Phoenixflame did switch to Rash, but was generally very quiet.

Another thing is that Rashkebab changed his vote to Hugman. Knowing that Rash is Mafia that could easily be to try to make Hugman seem innocent?

Phoenix fits the template of being mafia and since the mafia sacrificed the roleblocker to save him, he could likely be the godfather.

So the question is if Hugman is the goon or it is someone completely off the radar.

As far as I remember Hugman is playing his usual town game, we should go meta and read up on the old games.

Im not quite understanding why Yoica fears so much for his life.

[Yoica]

This is what I've been using to keep track of the votes.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1cug9IYNtsqvyPrEkQBjXNSmAgMjaAfg7p1acgMih8gg/edit?usp=sharing

Each column is a new vote. So Hug voted for Vorte 1st, then I did Inexcitus, Grish did Gaeios, etc.


I put myself near the top of my 'who I would kill'  list because I'm the only townie I'm 100% sure that is a townie. I'm fairly convinced Hug is a townie as well, but as linked above it wouldn't blindside me to find out he is mafia.

Gaeios and Grilly both make good analitical post, but day2 they vote on random ppl that has no practical chance to get lynched nor do they push their suspect foward when they notice others aren't joining in their vote. In other words fairly safe play for a mafia and not effective play for a townie.


Honestly the rest are a lot to read due to the lower frequency in their posting.

[Hugman]

So why didn't Rash fight for his life? Why did nobody try to defend him?

Clever mafia would make sure both of the other mafia got on that kill rash bandwagon to get some credit.

Indeed, we will have to look at this.

Another thing is that Rashkebab changed his vote to Hugman. Knowing that Rash is Mafia that could easily be to try to make Hugman seem innocent.

You could think that, but it's highly unlikely. Since I was the guy who instigated and pushed through the kill on Rash, and you may think both me and Rash are both, Mafia though it's very unlikely, and easily checked by the cop. The other implication that me, Rash and Phoenix are all Mafia is really really statistically unlikely. So what we all 3 happen to be Mafia and I roll a vote on Rash which also has a chance of getting the "3rd Mafia" Phoenix killed as well? Pretty damm stupid. It's time to check the voting records and who was resisting the lynch.

Im not quite understanding why Yoica fears so much for his life.

Yeah what's up with this? I could be killed cos of my activity but Yoica? Not sure why he's so worried?

Anyway on a train to work, let's see the night kill and check votes.

[Yoica]

Asking for a cop to check you is pointless if you are the Godfather

[Hugman]

Asking for a cop to check you is pointless if you are the Godfather

This is true. But me being the god father is a 1/13 chance, keep that in mind.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Asking for a cop to check you is pointless if you are the Godfather

Yeah the easily checked by COP suggestion is just silly. We dont know who the cop is, and he shouldnt reveal himself furthermore if you are the  godfather then it would be a false positive.

Do we get the murder in 15 minutes?

And no its 1/10 and probably 1/9 very soon.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

But Rash was also 1/11 and you were pretty damn sure about that.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Lovely quiet day at the office, almost completely empty because of autumn holidays.

[Hugman]

Having briefly checks you spreadsheet (which is quite useful if accurate) I have two points:

1. It assumes you are town, which from our point of view is a silly assumption.

2. Per the set up list, town should have 1cop, 1 doctor and one other special role (unless "named" doesn't count as one, even then it's 1/3 chance) so yeah that needs to be modified.

Nothing in there indicates why you would be so concerned of being killed tonight. Furthermore. The timing of posting this, BEFORE the night is over would make you MORE likely to be killed, this seems suspicious.

[Mouseh]

Good morning! Does the night ends 11am or 11pm?

[Cwave]

Good morning! Does the night ends 11am or 11pm?

In 2 minutes, the night ends.

[Cwave]

“The moment you doubt whether you can fly, you cease for ever to be able to do it.”

And fly Hugman did as he got zipped through several dimensions, ending up in the Emerald Nightmare. As he gained his footing, Hugman found himself surrounded by Shadow Pounders. He recognized one of his fellow Iron Edge raiders who stood before himself.

“Such a weak and simple subject, I’m already bored. I’ll just squash you like a bug and be done with it” the Raider said.

“Simple' does not mean 'easy'. I have learned that the things that seem the simplest are often the most powerful of all.”

Hugman replied as he threw off his raider disguise and showed his true from of the Orc Shaman Thrall, Son of Durotan.

The raider also threw off his human disguise and exposed himself, horns, hoofs and all. And epic battle ensued, many spells were cast and sadly, that one damn Shadow Pounder in the back was the one that got an hold of Thrall, The following Descent into Madness spell on him turned his body into a creature of madness. Maybe an raid expansion would see him getting freed by a brave group of IE raiders. For now, his spirit would wonder around in Azeroth.

Hugman aka Thrall, son of Durotan and the Town Cop has been killed.

Its’s now day 3. Day 3 ends tomorrow morning 11:00 GMT+1 20-10-2016.
Don’t forget to vote!

[Mouseh]

Uh, in case I get killed, one thing I would write: I was looking at vote pattern and previous posts, specially trying to figure out who that "old school IEdger" might be. Gaeios came up on first place, followed by Yoica. Hugman being mafia would be damn fun, but I think it is  far fetched now, tho should be considered, especially if in future he keeps suggesting targets for lynching (townies).