Mafia II - Story of the Iron Edge - Ship Deck

[Daekesh]

It's useful to go for everyone.  If they start making mistakes, lying, posting inconsistencies, that's how you learn who is mafia.

Some reason you don't want us interrogating her?

[Nachmanun]

It's dumb.
Focus it somewhere else, somewhere logical.

[Daekesh]

You know, I would be suspicious of you Nach, but that'd mean you would have to be THE worst mafia ever.

[Nachmanun]

Indeed, I don't think much of my actions thus far has made sense from the rebel PoV, albeit I bet some things sure look suspicious.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Im not gonna post here again until after dawn.

You are only helping the rebels to choose who they want to kill tonight.

As Imperials we dont want to provide the rebels with extra info. Let them decide who to kill based on what they have now and dont help them any further until dawn. Then we will have our 48 hours to decide who to lynch next....

[Daekesh]

Night is 24 hours, according to Palmar.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Yes it is. Which means that dawn is at 24:00 tonight.

Then we have a 48 hour day to decide the next lynch.

[Daekesh]

Ah, sorry, yes, misread what you said.

[Vorte]

Im not gonna post here again until after dawn.

Yes it is. Which means that dawn is at 24:00 tonight.

Then we have a 48 hour day to decide the next lynch.

Are you gonna start doing this again?

[Sintrael]

To be honest i'm a little suspect of nach's posts.

The first post he made after the lynch was to defer attention from it. No one was surprised that we lynched a green Nach, what I was surprised of at least was the speed at which the votes were changing, specificially toward sum1 who hadnt actually done much to warrent it and at how quiet kesh was about the whole thing (even when he wasnt raiding).

As i said in an earlier post, albeit much more briefly, the fact that we voted emptyy in based solely on that post he made, thinking he'd be clear and level headed, he then just hopped on the bandwagon with no warning, no explanation, no nothing. It was also his 2 votes that tipped the balance to intrinsic, again, no comment from him was made about this.

Another point that people have been touching on is the fact that Kesh was saved by all of this.


At this point i'm feeling pretty paranoid about the situation, but i'm not sure that i shouldnt be.

[shankski]

TBH, Intrinsic died for a good reason. He gave no input, put up no defence when was accused. I voted for Tronz first for the exact same reason however he posted his suspicions and put up a fight. Where as Intrinsic did hardly anything.

At this stage in the game it was almost guaranteed we would lynch a green, I'm just glad that a useless green was killed rather than someone who had put in some input and at least tried.

Obviously we can start analysing who voted for Intrinsic and maybe deduce a pattern by last minute switchers or anyone canvassing to get Intrinsic lynched. I am fully aware I may be on that list but in my opinion I made the right decision at the time.

Hopefully we will get some info after this night has passed too.

[Emptyy]

lol Emptyy maybe you should have thought of that before you ran for captain. I agree with Palmar on this one, as people were bound to talk on IRC it is fairer to all to do it here. Last evenings events were very interesting.

I thought of that, and perhaps running for captain wasn't the most brilliant of ideas. But at that time, I thought we had 48h on, 24h off, which would've made it doable.
I also think that having lower activity at night, giving us time to let the past 48 hours and 650 posts sink in will help us. This game might last for 3 weeks, and if we're going full speed all the time, I personally think it's going to be messy. Most of all, I think many players won't be able to stay up to date on what happens, which would be sad.

Emptyy joined the Intrinsic bandwagon because he suspected the rebels of bandwagoning Tronz...

My vote was on at that time on TTaM, due to trying to keep Kawe alive (as I said when I voted for TTaM).
Tronz was at the time the one with most votes and the obvious choice. However, he made some sensible posts, with valueable input and some new thoughts (which I don't think he got enough credit for). I mentioned this when voting for him. I do however, see the irony in saying "Bandwagon is bad" followed by jumping on another bandwagon. It was a 10PM-action, and I didn't think there was enough time to build up a case on someone 'new'.

I find drawing conclusions from posts only (on day 1) hard, and think that raw data such as vote-timeline and activity-statistics useful.
After the first night, data from killing etc. will help us.

 /not returning before Friday at 14.00.

[Daekesh]

If you're concerned about activity staying at these levels - it should be ok after the first week.  People will start dying and the activity will go down.

[Starbrow]

Updated the voting overview. Enjoy looking at the bandwagons

[Ino]

Updated the voting overview. Enjoy looking at the bandwagons

I'll just leave this irc log here .

 17:57   Globox          ? starbrow
 17:57   Globox          ? I don't recall voting for delling :b
 17:58   Globox          ? or am I reading it wrong
 17:59   Globox          ? afaik I only voted for kawe and archz
 17:59   Starbrow        ? oh cock did I mess up the lines again
 17:59   Globox          ? I guess you did
 17:59                   ? guanoape_ [~guanoape@ip565086b9.direct-adsl.nl] has joined #iron-edge
 17:59   Starbrow        ? bloody hell