Mafia IV - Lord of the Rings -

[Skymunken]

I still find it extremely odd for TTaM to call out red like that with no backup plan. Somethings not right...

[Palmar]

Don't wifom yourself too much about the setup. Cwave hasn't designed setups before, so I'm pretty sure he would not include ridiculous dumb stupid roles that are forced to roleclaim or something silly.

I mean, if matt had later entered the thread with some reasonable amount of time left in the day, and tried to explain his bullshit, I might have listened... but by now it's 3 hours left in the day.

He's the best lynch today. Any lynch we go for from now one is going to be a rushed dumb lynch that has no chance of hitting scum. If he flips town feel free to call me scum all you want.

[Palmar]

Not to mention, policy lynching stupid shit like this might improve play in IE games.

[Grilldyret]

I'm starting to lean towards lynching TTaM. If he has some power that keeps him from being lynched on day 1, at least we know mroe about who his supporters are. If he doesn't, well then it's just plain silly to make such statements, and he deserves a policy lynch.

Problem is, though, that if TTaM has some counterattack or we can't afford to miss one lynch, we'll be screwed.

[Hugman]

So.....

Kesh claims Red,  asks greens/blues to out blues, and then votes for Nach "Because he is the only one that suggested actually outing a blue?"

This is weird.

[Nachmanun]

He could just be the village idiot aswell...

I'm too curious by now to not vote for him.

[Palmar]

There's actually a decent chance, given his vote on nachmanun, that this ridiculous gambit is something he thought of as town.

I need to rethink this shit over a dota game. Will let you know.

[Yoica]

I'm in dubio between Surim and Skymunken. They tend follow/reword what others have written in away that doesn't sit right with me. I get the feeling they are on opposite teams although I'm not sure which one is red and which one is green/blue.

TTaM is just one riddle. First he only makes 1 odd post and hours later votes for Nach without posting.

[Skymunken]

So far I've just been trying to point out that I find the whole TTaM thing sticky.

In my head, Palmar sticks out abit because he seems quick to jump to his gun, but I can't entirely blame him since it's day one and information is scattered.

Same goes for Tyler, he was straight on boat with the "TTaM claimed red, therefore he is red."

Surim seems to follow Palmar abit, which I can understand since this is his one of his first games, and I'm sort of in the same boat, kinda holding back about speaking up. But there are still some weird things about Surim that Eetion also pointed out.

My question to Grilly: If we lynch TTaM, and that fails, how would we know more about anyone? We would know that TTaM was lynch-immune, we would probably lose a green or blue, and we go back to square one. We could then try to re-lynch TTaM hoping it was a one night thing, but in my mind, right now he has a guardian angel over his head.

[Skymunken]

All we can assume is that the red knows more about TTaM than we do, chances are this is a stunt to convince us to lynch him, wasting our first lynch if it does turn out there was a form of lynch-immunity in play.

[Grilldyret]

My question to Grilly: If we lynch TTaM, and that fails, how would we know more about anyone? We would know that TTaM was lynch-immune, we would probably lose a green or blue, and we go back to square one. We could then try to re-lynch TTaM hoping it was a one night thing, but in my mind, right now he has a guardian angel over his head.

It's quite obvious which participants that have pressed on for a TTaM lynch. Palmar and Tyler seem to have no doubt in mind that this is the best thing to do, so if TTaM has some sort of immunity or retalliation, that would put them in a bad light for the coming days.

I'm not saying that it's irrational to go for TTaM's throat, after all he DID claim he was red. I'm just surprised to see that the above mentioned individuals don't seem to realise there's something sketchy about this opening.

[Palmar]

Fuck it, this is probably the dumbest town idea I've ever seen. Let's not lynch matt.

I don't want to lynch surim, sky, eetion, yoica either.

[Palmar]

Ok let's lynch tyler instead, he is probably scum.

[Hugman]

Fuck it, this is probably the dumbest town idea I've ever seen. Let's not lynch matt.

I don't want to lynch surim, sky, eetion, yoica either.

Uturn.

[Palmar]

I might also be open to lynching nachmanun or maix, although maix seems less likely to be scum than the other two.

Is grilly even playing? It's not good when people forget you, that means you're useless.

Grish is just a complete null at the moment.