Main Menu

Wow Forever

Our guild is called Iron Edge Forever in WoW Forever.

Iron Edge Discord

Recent

Recent Logs

Welcome to Iron Edge. Please login or sign up.

14 Guests, 0 Users

Apply to Iron Edge

Choose the type of application above.

Sherlock Holmes

Started by Ameliorate, February 01, 2010, 09:33:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Karga

the movie was just entertaining. The theme was nice, a little exotic, mystic...
Funny aswell.
Robert Downey Jr.'s acting was very good.
But in the end, it was just an entertainment. 5.5/10
君に魔法をかけて蛙にしてやろう。 (i'll bewitch you into a frog!)

Aleandro

Quote from: Karga on April 06, 2010, 10:47:45 PM
But in the end, it was just an entertainment. 5.5/10

Wondering what more u expect from movie, cookies? :D
BTW how can u give it 5,5/10 and 6/10 to The heart locker Oo ,as that one wasnt even entertainment just a tale for kiddos. :P

Karga

#17
it was cinematically successfull ! that's all man :]
i watch a lot of movies, and there are movies far better.

ah yes, cookies would be cool :] i may add a bonus of 0.5 for +cookie.  :P
i expect a perfect storytelling, perfect acting, perfect direction of photography,
perfect music, and more..
The Genre of Sherlock Holmes is not the same. In his own genre it was successful. And that's why it has similar points with "Hurt Locker". Nonetheless, Hurt Locker is far better in a lot of values.

http://xoops.iron-edge.co.uk/forum-new/index.php?topic=2684.0
here, a movie far better in my opinion.
君に魔法をかけて蛙にしてやろう。 (i'll bewitch you into a frog!)