Mafia - The story of Edgeville - Town Square

[Cwave]

does anyone know if Tyler plays poker?
it would be almost giving Tyler a double kill if he is mafia. both lynching an innocent and wasting a doctor.

That's a very valid question for you , Tyler.....!

[Tyler]

I have played a little poker :) Not much though, and I am worse than I hoped to be. Terrible at bluffing!

This would be an "all in" bluff from me if I was mafia scum. I don't think I would ever be that brave. I fear are straying into over analysis here.

[Hugman]

The more I think about it the more I feel I should just stick with my gut feeling. Lynch Hugman! We can't afford miss this oportunity. Those  mobsters will try and kill someone in the night, making it even harder to get a lynch vote.

I could start talking about how his main defence was to lash out at me, not protest his own innocence, but I fear that is over analyising. It might make me look pretty silly if i'm wrong too..

P.S. wtb doc protection for tonight

   Ha. Tbh I didn't feel the need to "protest my own innocence" as you put it, since I wasn't the one throwing around "lets all gather and lynch him based on my individual gut feeling!". But if it makes anyone feel any better:

I am not a Mafioso, I am a Townie.

It doesn't come much clearer than that.

You on the other hand, continue to make odd statements.

   This whole "oh... bluffing...good heavens no! I do think I could do that, frightfully wicked business; oh I need to go lie down, I feel a little faint." act is very amusing. Utterly unconvincing, but rather amusing never the less. Does anyone really believe you wouldn't be capable of bluffing on a forum ?

  And now I see you are calling for a Doc protection... Which  in my book is strike number two, as we know you aren't the cop, so Its a rather strange thing to ask for, as It wouldn't save you if you really were the cop, after drawing that much attention to yourself. If you were a townie, calling for it would be a rather selfish act, as it deprives it off important blues, like the Cop/vig/tracker, which to the town as a whole, are far more important. No, most likely you are a mob, and are calling for this on the hope you can get a lynching kill, 2 night kills, and waste our doc save.

Very suspicious.

[Daekesh]

How do we know Tyler isn't the cop?  And why would you narrow the number of Mafia targets?!

[Hugman]

How do we know Tyler isn't the cop?  And why would you narrow the number of Mafia targets?!

   Simply because the Cop (and the other blues) needs to survive the first night to have any effect. Calling for the doc, is pointless if the mob think he is a cop, as they get two kills, which ensure his death, if they know its him. If they are smart the blues are lying low right now, until they can get some info after the first night.

The main people who will be posting at this point will be towies (like me) who have no powers and can only have an effect in this game by posting info or discussions which direct ppl to lynch the right dudes and provoke foolish mafia responses ; or mobsters which just tend to try and turn one against one another, and jump on lynching bandwagons.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

Im at the point where I think Hugman and Tyler are just two inbred townies not worth voting for. On the other hand they could both be mafia trying to confuse us.

Think Im gonna go for my first thought and vote for arches.

[Cwave]

If they are smart the blues are....

This choice of words fits a mobster, speaking of the blues in the 3rd person. :x

[Cwave]

And i don't understand why Ino hasn't voted yet.

[Shiftey]

LYNCH HIM!

[Hugman]

If they are smart the blues are....

This choice of words fits a mobster, speaking of the blues in the 3rd person. :x

Yes... that's totally relevant.

I know I am a townie. Tyler could be a mobster, or could be a townie like me, and we could both be being idiots...

Cwave on the other hand, hasn't posted much, and what he has tends to be single line accusations without any sort of logical back up, or reasoning. And he was very quick to change his vote to jumping on the bandwagon of voting me, without any sort of explanation.

I may have to change my vote.

[Cwave]

I decided to vote on you based on clear reasoning by Tyler and the fact that by that reasoning, you have the biggest chance of being a mobster in our town.

Unless someone else makes a mistake and reveals himself as a mobster, my vote stands for now.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

check Irc logs from last night. Arches might be mafia

[delling2]

Hmm, I think I actually agree with Hugman in this case. I think Cwave could be a mobster.

[Tyler]

The thing is a split vote means nothing really. If we all vote for who we think is the most likely a mobster we will probably never lynch anyone. We have to find a way of getting a majority. This will become harder and harder as the mob whack the good guys.

I guess it would not be the end of the world if the first day is split though, better than lynching an innocent. However if we are going to take chances the earlier the better. Hmm I am conficted.

[Gaeios(Graxlos)]

So we can choose not to lynch anyone?