Mafia II - Story of the Iron Edge - Ship Deck

[Hugman]

Nice post Grish 

Though disgruntled pilots have reason to turn rebel.

[delling2]

(Don't want to derail, but that was an amazing post, Grish, you big... roleplayer, you!)

Damn, both Shiftey and Hugman put forward strong cases for Kawe and Arches.

[Grishnag]

well the rebels ARE the reason i get drafted in to this military

##Support: Kawe

since he played a mighty fine game last time

[Eetion]

Since it is day one, and there is no basis whatsoever proving someone is or isn't rebel, I would rather go with someone I have seen to be useless to the Empire. If he is Imperial, and he hangs, well then we can use the data on who contributed to getting him hanged, to help sort out our rebel suspects.

Arches doesn't play intelligently as a green. He jokes around and confuses people, and then wonders why they all suspect him, which, if he is Imperial, is counter productive.

I strongly agree with what Hug is pointing out here, losing him might be for the greater good if he turns up as Imperial.

[Eetion]

well the rebels ARE the reason i get drafted in to this military

##Support: Kawe

since he played a mighty fine game last time

I'm still of the belief that it is too weak of an argument that "kawe played well last game" to elect him Captain.

[Yoica]

True Et, but with limited knowledge decisions need to be based on something.

[Archz]

Arches doesn't play intelligently as a green. He jokes around and confuses people, and then wonders why they all suspect him, which, if he is Imperial, is counter productive.

If I were mafia, you really think that I would stir up some heat on the very first day? Every argument to lynch me I've heard is just "buhu he played bad the first game, let's kill him" and frankly you are either retarded or a mafia trying to score a early kill and hoping it won't come back to you.

Pay close attention to the votes, if all the mafia vote for the same person, they are likely to get a lynch since we no longer need the majority

[Eetion]

With limited knowledge Yoica, i see Vdti as a relatively safer choice of election than Kawe.
See it like this.

All the imperials are a card of the 13 cards in a suit.

A strong player (could be Kawe) is thought of as an Ace.

Why elect someone who is already at the top lvl of the deck to be more powerful, when he is already a strong asset to the team. When the reasons of doing this is "He played well last game" is the actual only one.

Instead elect someone that you aswell based on this small amount of knowledge can believe is part of the Empire, so that we can get a 2nd Ace should Kawe be either manipulating or shot dead. Spreading the Aces is better than focusing on having 1 trumph card should it be eliminated.

[Doomslay]

All these people that are early jumping onto arches is pretty worrying. Keep an eye on early voters, its pretty easy to get people off your trail if you start shouting someone's name and everyone joins in.

[delling2]

Archz -- the problem is that we can't trust you to play sensibly. It doesn't matter what colour you are if you're not reliable.

Imagine going to war, but you've got a crazy guy in your squadron who just can't keep his mouth shut. You either kill him yourself, or he shouts in the middle of the night and draws attention to your entire squad.

Greater good and all that!

[Hugman]

Pay close attention to the votes, if all the mafia vote for the same person, they are likely to get a lynch since we no longer need the majority

   Except that there is currently 21 Imperials to 6 Rebels. If all the Rebels vote for the same person, that would be retared, as it would cast suspicion on all of them. No more likely they will spread it a bit, maybe throwing 3 towards getting an Imperial lynch.

  While I am voting the way I am, based upon what I stated earlier, I am also watching if anyone comes to you defense Arches, as that will help me decide if you have any rebel supporters or not. If no one speaks in your defense, it could be likely you are Imperial. But that gets into heavy WIFOM.

Anyway, you have brought this upon yourself Arches, by your actions. Unless we can shake lose another, better candidate to be Rebel (which as I stated before, at this point, there is no reliable proof whatsoever), it makes sound logic, to go with what I stated.

[Archz]

Fuck it, I give up. Good luck

[Palmar]

Courtesy of Matt, who is both a gentleman and an awesome programmer, we now have an IRC bot that counts the votes for us.

It will only count properly formatted votes, so you better bloody do it right. Remember the bolded part and remember the hash tags.

You can check the current score on IRC using !mafia votes

[Hugman]

Fuck it, I give up. Good luck

(Goes and grabs the "doing a Shiftey" stamp)

Its the first 24 hours of day 1.

Be less of a retard.

[shankski]

Fuck it, I give up. Good luck

Modkill inc?